Wednesday, 31 May 2017

A Physical Demonstration Is Worth A Thousand Expert Opinions (warning, ugly sound)

quote [ Key point ... the only difference between the two wheel runs with and without the splash plate is the direction of movement. The run with the splash plate is overcoming the opposing force of the wheel/bearing/friction of the outer wheel (that is left over after inner wheel angular cancels out some of it) which is what I did the single wheel runs to isolate/illustrate. ]

We will be putting up a video of a motorized version with vertical wheels and water circulation.
At present it weighs four times as much and has around a quarter of the power output but at least it doesn't transmit any angular momentum to the pendulum from wheel/bearing/motor forces.
We're still fiddling with it but the video should be up soon.


All of this "space drive" stuff aside ... the primary motivation for this video is to demonstrate that a rotating wheel of water, with a controlled "leak", presents the kind of unbalanced force that one can only attain via the application of an "outside force", which in this case is Centrifugal Acceleration occurring inside the wheel.
It is very unfortunate that generations of students have conflated "outside force" with "outside of the container" (though most of the time the terms are admittedly interchangeable).

Normally a balanced rotating body that loses some of its mass will encounter an acceleration of its axis in the direction opposite of the flight path of the lost mass (due to the sudden condition of imbalance) but in this system the centrifugal force works with the water still in the wheel to maintain even distribution of mass and prevents imbalances in the same manner as a LeBlanc Balancer such as are used today in washing machines and some industrial/automotive capacities.
[SFW] [science & technology] [+3 Interesting]
[by -_-]
<-- Entry / Comment History

donnie said @ 10:31am GMT on 5th June
You know face, at this point I just feel bad for you. You've put so much time and energy into this plainly hopeless device. NASA gets so many of these amazing breakthroughs submitted to them annually that they have even drafted guidance documents to help the people in the outreach departments deal with them. Why you think your impossible mechanical machine is any more special than the hundreds of others out there that don't work, I don't understand.

donnie said @ 10:35am GMT on 5th June
You know face, at this point I just feel bad for you. You've put so much time and energy into this plainly hopeless device. NASA gets so many of these amazing breakthroughs submitted to them annually that they have even drafted guidance documents to help the people in the outreach departments deal with them. Why you think your impossible mechanical machine is any more special than the thousands of others out there that don't work, I don't understand.


<-- Entry / Current Comment
donnie said @ 10:31am GMT on 5th June
You know face, at this point I just feel bad for you. You've put so much time and energy into this plainly hopeless device. NASA gets so many of these amazing breakthroughs submitted to them annually that they have even drafted guidance documents to help the people in the outreach departments deal with them. Why you think your impossible mechanical machine is any more special than the thousands of others out there that don't work, I don't understand.



Posts of Import
Karma
SE v2 Closed BETA
First Post
Subscriptions and Things

Karma Rankings
ScoobySnacks
HoZay
Paracetamol
lilmookieesquire
Ankylosaur